Arraignment as the Initial Judicial Step
Judges are authorized and required to conduct an arraignment—serving as a probable cause hearing—as the initial step in the judicial process, immediately following the arrest of a Defendant.
Purpose of Arraignment:
- To determine whether sufficient probable cause exists to support the charges filed against a Defendant.
- To ensure that the charges are substantiated by preliminary evidence before proceeding to full judicial action.
- To prevent unnecessary case filings for matters lacking adequate legal basis.
Conduct of Arraignment Hearings
During an arraignment, the presiding Judge will:
- Review all initial evidence presented by law enforcement.
- Consider statements from the Prosecution and/or Defense, if either party is available.
- Evaluate the totality of evidence and circumstances to determine if probable cause exists.
If probable cause is established:
- The case may proceed to a formal trial or plea hearing, and a Bail Hearing may follow.
- Bail conditions or detainment may be determined at the Judge's discretion, based on the severity of charges, flight risk, and safety concerns.
If probable cause is not established:
- Charges may be dismissed or modified.
- The Defendant will be released immediately unless other valid legal grounds exist for detainment.
- Law enforcement may re-file charges at a later date through a warrant, should new or additional evidence emerge.
Bail Hearings
Bail Hearings shall be conducted only after the arraignment and a determination of probable cause has been made.
During the Bail Hearing, the Judge will consider:
- The nature and severity of the charges.
- The Defendant’s criminal history, if any.
- Risk of flight or threat to public safety.
- Recommendations from the Prosecution or Defense, when applicable.
Bail may be granted with or without conditions, including supervised release, curfews, or other court-imposed restrictions. In severe cases, the Judge may order remand without bail.
Coordination and Evidence Requirements
To ensure the success of this policy:
- Law enforcement agencies must be prepared to submit relevant preliminary evidence and reports promptly upon arrest.
- Prosecution and Defense representatives are encouraged, but not required, to be present at arraignments.
- Judges will receive training to ensure they are proficient in assessing probable cause and conducting efficient arraignments.
Violation of Bail Bonds
WARNING
Violation of Bail Bonds will result in a warrant being issued for the subjects arrest under §300.17 - Violation of Bail Bond Terms. It is solely the defendants responsibility to comply with all orders of the court.
